For teachers

Free critical thinking lessons for your classroom

Printable 20- to 30-minute lessons for Grades 4 to 10, aligned to Common Core RI.4.8 to RI.8.8. Classroom packs work any time of year, and seasonal packs tie into the holidays.

Free download, no sign-up · Available through December 1

Thanksgiving: Hasty Generalization vs. Part-Whole Mix-Up

Bad Sample (Hasty Generalization) + Part-Whole Mix-Up (Composition and Division)

This seasonal pack breaks down two common reasoning mistakes: jumping to conclusions about a group based on too few examples or too little evidence (hasty generalization) and wrongly assuming that what is true of the parts must be true of the whole, or vice versa (composition and division). While both mistakes involve moving between individuals and larger groups, they fail for completely different reasons.

Want the whole library? Create a free teacher account.

What's in each pack

  • • Short arguments where students identify the flaw from 2–3 options and explain why the reasoning fails
  • • A documented real-world case with discussion questions
  • • Teacher notes and a 20- to 30-minute lesson flow
  • • An answer key with full explanations

Your free account includes

Classroom packs, all year

  • Classroom Pack 1: Attacks the Person (Ad Hominem) + Twisted Argument (Straw Man)

Seasonal packs

  • Thanksgiving: Hasty Generalization vs. Part-Whole Mix-Up

New classroom and seasonal packs are added through the year.

Get free access

Use your school or educator email for immediate access after email verification. Personal email services like Gmail and Yahoo require review.

Already registered? Teacher log in

Printable lessons only. No student accounts and no student data.