
Why I built Mind Merit
Hi, I'm Rachel Sheffield, the founder of Mind Merit.
For more than 20 years, I've taught logical reasoning and critical thinking to college students across the country, and I love doing it. But over those years, I noticed that students were arriving less and less able to think critically about what they read, or to say why an argument doesn't make sense.
So I started teaching my own kids (ages 10, 10 and 7) the basic flaws of reasoning, using fun, engaging arguments. Then I started building something so they could practice more and have fun doing it. They loved it, and frankly, I think it's amazing. So I decided to open it up to other families and classrooms.
Research shows that critical thinking isn't something kids just absorb. It has to be taught deliberately, just like reading comprehension or long division. But very few schools teach it directly.
And with the rise of AI and short-form content, it's more important to teach than ever. AI can give a confident and completely wrong answer. Social media posts often use clickbait headlines without any solid evidence behind them. The skill that protects a kid from that isn't memorizing more facts. It's knowing what good reasoning looks like, and recognizing when it's missing.
What Mind Merit is
Mind Merit is a 10-minute daily game for kids in grades 4 to 10. It has two tracks:
- Argument Sorter, where kids learn to separate what someone is claiming from the evidence they give to back it up.
- Flaw Hunter, where they practice identifying 25 classic logical fallacies through short, relatable scenarios designed to challenge their thinking.
The questions adjust to each kid's skill, not their grade, so they stay challenged without getting buried. Every question explains why the reasoning falls apart. And every Monday there's a real example from history, advertising, science or politics, so kids see these mistakes outside the game.
Kids earn diamonds that hatch creature companions and unlock other ways to customize their game. Seasonal editions bring limited-edition creatures, too.
What I care about
- Accuracy first. I teach this for a living, so accuracy has been a priority in building Mind Merit. If your child learns a fallacy from Mind Merit, it's the same fallacy a logic course would teach, just explained in an age-appropriate way. The game is designed to help kids slow down and really think about what they read.
- Respect for kids. No babyish tone and no "brain puzzle" gimmicks. A 10-year-old can handle real vocabulary when you explain it once.
- Fair examples. Real-world cases come from a variety of time periods, are balanced, and are never about current politics. The goal is to teach kids HOW to think, not WHAT to think.
- A safe place to practice. No ads, no in-app purchases, and student data is never sold.
- Parents and teachers in the loop. Parents see the three fallacies their child misses most, each with a short guide and extra examples so you can talk it through at home. Teachers get free lessons and worksheets at mindmerit.co/teachers.
A note from me
Mind Merit is small and independent, and I read every email. If something's confusing, or there's a fallacy you'd like to see added, write to me at hello@mindmerit.co. I'd love to hear from you!
Rachel Sheffield
Founder, Mind Merit
