Cum Hoc Fallacy
Kid-friendly name: Correlation ≠ Causation
A correlation ≠ causation fallacy (cum hoc ergo propter hoc, if you want to speak in Latin) is when someone assumes that because two things change together, one of them must be causing the other.
Correlation is when two variables move together. As one shifts, the other tends to shift too. For example, the number of pirates on the high seas has fallen sharply since the 1800s, and global average temperatures have climbed over the same stretch. That's a correlation.
Causation is a bigger claim: that the change in one variable actually produces the change in the other. Here, that would mean pirates were somehow holding global warming at bay, and that losing them is what caused the planet to heat up. Which is ridiculous. (The pirate chart is a famous joke from a 2005 satirical letter by Bobby Henderson, written to make exactly this point.) Correlation is a good reason to consider causation, but it doesn't prove causation, as any pirate will tell you.
To Introduce the Concept
Biscuit the BeagleDoes Biscuit's barking make the mail truck leave?
Read more →
Does Biscuit's barking make the mail truck leave?
Every afternoon at three, the mail truck turns onto our street, and every afternoon at three, Biscuit the beagle hurls himself at the window barking like the fate of the house depends on it. Without fail, the truck drives away within a minute or two. Biscuit is completely convinced he's the reason the evil truck leaves.
The truck was going to leave either way. It's finishing its stop on the route, not responding to the bark. When evaluating this, some kids say it's the truck's arrival, not its departure, that sets Biscuit off in the first place. That's true, but it explains why he barks, not why the truck leaves.
Biscuit is ignoring a confounding variable: something that influences both the supposed cause and the supposed effect. Here, the two things he links together, his barking and the truck pulling away, are both caused by the same thing: the mail route. The schedule brings the truck to the curb, which sets him off, and that same schedule sends the truck off a minute or two later. Neither the barking nor the departure causes the other.
In the Wild
1999–2000The Night-Light ScareA striking pattern led to warnings about babies sleeping with night-lights, but they ignored a missing piece of the puzzle.
Read more →
A striking pattern led to warnings about babies sleeping with night-lights, but they ignored a missing piece of the puzzle.
In May 1999, CNN ran the headline "Night-light may lead to nearsightedness." The story covered a study in Nature by researchers at the University of Pennsylvania and the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia.
The researchers surveyed the parents of 479 children, ages 2 to 16, who had been seen at a hospital eye clinic. Parents were asked how their child's bedroom had been lit at night before age two. Among children who had slept in darkness, 10 percent were nearsighted. The figure rose to 34 percent for children who had slept with a night-light and 55 percent for those who had slept with a room light on.
It was a striking pattern: the more nighttime light, the more myopia (the medical term for nearsightedness). But the study was observational, not a controlled experiment. Nobody randomly assigned babies to sleep in darkness or with a light, so the pattern alone couldn't show that light caused the eye problem. The authors said as much. The headlines were less careful, and the scare stuck around. More than 25 years later, pediatric eye doctors still write posts reassuring parents that night-lights don't cause nearsightedness.
Checking the result
In March 2000, Nature published two independent studies that failed to find the same link. A team led by Karla Zadnik at Ohio State examined 1,220 schoolchildren. Myopia rates were 20 percent among children who had slept in darkness, 17 percent among those with a night-light, and 22 percent among those with a room light on. Those differences were small and not statistically significant. (Only 45 children in that sample had slept with a room light on, so that last figure is the least precise.) A second team, led by Jane Gwiazda at the New England College of Optometry, studied 213 children and also found no link.
A third factor
The later studies pointed to a likely common cause: the parents' own eyesight. Nearsighted parents were more likely to leave a light on, perhaps because they need it to see, and their children were more likely to become nearsighted too, whether through genes, shared habits, or both. The 1999 study hadn't accounted for this.
There may have been a sampling problem too. The 1999 study drew its children from an eye clinic, while the Ohio State sample came from ordinary schools. Kids who end up at an eye clinic may not look like kids in general.
Sources: CNN, "Night-light may lead to nearsightedness" (May 1999); Graham E. Quinn et al., "Myopia and ambient lighting at night," Nature 399, 113–114 (1999); Karla Zadnik et al., "Myopia and ambient night-time lighting," Nature 404, 143–144 (2000); Jane Gwiazda et al., "Myopia and ambient night-time lighting," Nature 404, 144 (2000); Ohio State University News (2000); National Eye Institute (2000)
Can you think of two things that always seem to happen together? Does one actually cause the other, or is something else behind both?
This is 1 fallacy. Mind Merit covers 25.
Mind Merit's Correlation ≠ Causation Family Guide
- •More examples: Fun, simple examples to illustrate the flaw.
- •More real-world cases: Real-world examples to dig into the flaw in more detail.
- •Family guidance: How to teach recognizing the fallacy to your family.
Inside Mind Merit

Learn to separate the main conclusion from the evidence backing it up.

Learn to spot the flaw in the reasoning, even when the conclusion seems convincing.
- •Adaptive practice: Questions adjust automatically as reasoning improves, keeping practice challenging without being overwhelming.
- •Parent dashboard: Track which logic skills are clicking, and where your student needs more practice.
