Free printable
Critical Thinking Worksheet
Five flawed arguments to spot, one true story to talk through together, and an answer key for you. Made for ages 10+ (Grades 4-10). It takes about 20 minutes.
Download PDFOpen the downloaded file to print it or share it with a teacher.
Page 1 · Flaw Hunter
Spot the Flaw

Each argument below has a flaw in its reasoning. Pick the flaw from the list of possible fallacies (two won't be used), then explain in your own words why the reasoning doesn't make sense.
Possible Fallacies
- • Attacks the Person (Ad Hominem)
- • Bandwagon
- • Black and White (False Dilemma)
- • Circular Reasoning
- • Correlation ≠ Causation (Cum Hoc)
- • Slippery Slope
- • Twisted Argument (Straw Man)
1. Ms. Hernandez told her class that the mystery novel they're about to read is one of the most gripping books she's ever encountered. Marcus leaned over and whispered that Ms. Hernandez wears the most boring beige loafers imaginable — so clearly she has terrible taste, and the book will be awful.
Flaw: ______________________________
Explain why the reasoning doesn't make sense.
2. Nadia suggested that the third-grade art club buy one box of neon glitter for the bulletin board. Leo objected, saying that filling the entire classroom with five feet of blinding glitter so nobody could open the doors would destroy the school.
Flaw: ______________________________
Explain why the reasoning doesn't make sense.
3. Ranger Chen warned that if visitors feed even one chip crumb to a squirrel, the squirrels will develop a taste for salt, demand vending machines in the forest, organize an armed takeover of the ranger station, and eventually force humans to forage for acorns.
Flaw: ______________________________
Explain why the reasoning doesn't make sense.
4. The Maplewood Public Library noticed that on days when the librarian plays classical music softly in the reading room, more books are checked out than average. Library board member Ms. Holt declared that classical music is proven to make people want to read more.
Flaw: ______________________________
Explain why the reasoning doesn't make sense.
5. Over a thousand apprentices signed up for Professor Bumble's levitation workshop this semester. It must be the most effective way to learn flight magic in the kingdom.
Flaw: ______________________________
Explain why the reasoning doesn't make sense.
Page 2 · Real-World Example
Ignaz Semmelweis

Vienna, 1847

If a man is insufferable, are his conclusions wrong?
In the 1840s, physician Ignaz Semmelweis worked at Vienna General Hospital, a facility with two distinct maternity clinics. In the clinic staffed by doctors and medical students, approximately 1 in 10 mothers died of childbed fever. In the clinic run by midwives, the mortality rate was less than 1 in 25. The crucial variable was that doctors frequently arrived at deliveries directly from performing autopsies, whereas midwives did not. In 1847, Semmelweis mandated that the doctors wash their hands in a chlorine solution. Mortality in his clinic plummeted from 18 percent in April to roughly 2 percent by that summer. He later replicated these empirical results at a hospital in Pest, Hungary.
Despite this evidence, the medical establishment largely rejected his findings. Part of this resistance was theoretical: the germ theory of disease had not yet been established, leaving Semmelweis unable to offer a biological mechanism to explain *why* his protocol worked. But part of it was social. His claims offended the sensibilities of the era, implying that educated professionals were the carriers of a fatal disease. In America, the prominent obstetrician Charles D. Meigs, rejecting a similar warning from Oliver Wendell Holmes, is widely quoted as saying that *doctors are gentlemen, and gentlemen's hands are clean.* In essence, many physicians let their own social standing outweigh the data.
Faced with this resistance, Semmelweis grew notoriously combative. In open letters, he publicly denounced his critics as murderers. Many of his critics answered in kind, going after the man and his book rather than his numbers, with one reviewer mocking his text as "the Koran of puerperal theology." This is the hazard of the *ad hominem* fallacy: to the extent that the medical community let its distaste for Semmelweis's abrasive personality shape its evaluation of his clinical data, it was reasoning badly. The mortality rates, of course, were entirely independent of his character.
Semmelweis died in an asylum in 1865 at the age of 47, ironically from an infected wound. Within a few years, the pioneering work of Louis Pasteur and Joseph Lister would finally provide the theoretical framework explaining why Semmelweis's handwashing protocol had been correct all along.
***
**Sources:** Michael Best and Duncan Neuhauser, ["Ignaz Semmelweis and the birth of infection control"](https://qualitysafety.bmj.com/content/13/3/233), *Quality and Safety in Health Care* (2004); K. Codell Carter and Barbara R. Carter, *Childbed Fever: A Scientific Biography of Ignaz Semmelweis* (1994)
Talk it through
- 1. Semmelweis's critics said he was rude, odd, and foreign. Even if all of that was true, why doesn't it answer whether hand-washing saved lives?
- 2. What evidence could his critics have looked at instead of looking at him?
- 3. Some doubts were fair, since nobody yet knew about germs. How is "we don't know why it works yet" different from "he's insufferable"?
- 4. Suppose a classmate you often disagree with points out a safety problem. How could you make sure you judge the warning, not the person?
For parents
Answer Key

1. Attacks the Person (Ad Hominem)
What Ms. Hernandez wears on her feet has absolutely nothing to do with whether a mystery novel is actually gripping. A person's shoe choices and their literary judgment are completely unrelated. Dismissing a recommendation by attacking the person's fashion sense instead of reading the book is an attack the person (ad hominem) fallacy.
2. Twisted Argument (Straw Man)
Nadia only asked for one box of glitter for a display board. Leo pretended she wanted to flood the room with feet of glitter and argued against that instead. Distorting the original idea into an absurd disaster is a twisted argument fallacy.
3. Slippery Slope
Ranger Chen leaps from a single chip crumb to full squirrel world domination, with no evidence that any step in the chain would actually lead to the next. Each link — vending machines, armed takeover, humans foraging for acorns — is assumed inevitable rather than argued for. Treating one small action as the trigger for an unstoppable catastrophic sequence is a slippery slope fallacy.
4. Correlation ≠ Causation (Cum Hoc)
Higher checkouts and classical music both show up on certain days, but other things could explain the pattern — those might be days with popular new arrivals or better weather keeping people inside. Two things appearing together doesn't establish cause. That's a correlation ≠ causation fallacy.
5. Bandwagon
This is a bandwagon fallacy. The sheer number of enrolled students proves the workshop is popular or heavily advertised, but it does not prove the teaching method is effective. Popularity cannot substitute for evidence of actual learning outcomes.
Give your kids 5 minutes of critical thinking practice every day.
Mind Merit turns this into daily practice that adapts to your child. Try it free for 7 days at mindmerit.co.
Like this? Get one flawed argument by email every day.
